SEO in 2017 – 10 Highly Relevant Questions Answered by Top SEO Experts.

Kavin Paulson
Published on December 8, 2016
Barry Schwartz, Founder of Search Engine Roundtable

Since 2013, we had been doing SEO surveys annually (Check out the surveys we conducted in 2013, 2014 & 2015). The objective had been to take the pulse of the SEO community and also to enlighten our readers about the key developments happening in the SEO landscape. Expert opinions are important because they help the industry to speculate less and strategize better for the future.

This year, instead of conducting a survey, we decided to approach some of the top SEO experts in the industry with some specific questions very relevant to the developments happening in the SEO landscape. We thought their answers/opinions would help our readers understand the currently changing SEO scenario and also the key changes we can possibly expect to happen in 2017. We hope this post will help you to take some proactive measures to be prepared to adapt to the upcoming key changes in 2017.


Below are the questions we asked them and the respective answers given by them. Here we go…

Eric Enge – Author, Speaker, Digital Marketing Consultant and CEO at Stone Temple Consulting Corporation. Follow him on Twitter.

Eric Enge, CEO of Stone Temple


What will be the impact of Google’s upcoming separate Mobile Index on SEO in 2017?

Eric Enge:

The biggest impact will be the fact that they will begin crawling site’s on a mobile first basis. That means the crawl path in your mobile experience will dictate how Google finds pages on your site. There are many companies that have thought long and hard about content discovery in a desktop environment, but that have not put any effort into thinking about that in their mobile experience. This could significantly impact the discovery and indexation of their content.

It underscores the importance of reviewing your site primarily from a Smartphone device, and, in fact, doing that before you review it from a desktop device. Too many brands are not doing this. Yet, we have many clients at Stone Temple where 60% or 70% of their visitors come from Smartphones to their site. The key change that brands need to make in 2017 is to stop talking about being mobile first and actually start being mobile first.

Barry Schwartz – Author, Speaker, SEO Consultant and CEO of RustyBrick, a New York Web Service Firm. Founder of Search Engine Roundtable and News Editor at Search Engine Land. Follow him on Twitter.

Barry Schwartz, Founder of Search Engine Roundtable


If you have to make one major prediction for SEO in 2017, what would that be?

Barry Schwartz:

So if I took the easy route, I would predict that mobile will grow even faster in terms of importance with SEO in 2017. With the Google announcement on the mobile-first index being the clear indicator there.

But if I want to be bolder, I’d predict that AI and machine learning will take even more control over the Google search algorithm in 2017.

Aaron Wall – SEO Consultant and the Founder of SEOBook. Follow him on Twitter.

Aaron Wall, CEO of SEO Book


With respect to the upcoming Google’s separate mobile index, there is a concern that mobile content tends to have fewer links. How do you think Google will tackle this challenge? Also, please clarify this for our readers – Isn’t that only a concern for people who have separate mobile sites? Owners of responsive websites or sites that use same urls to serve same content across devices, don’t have to worry about this, right?

Aaron Wall:

From the sounds of it

The index will be mobile-first in terms of using the content on the mobile version of a site to drive rankings for both mobile & desktop searches

If there is no mobile version of a page then the desktop version will rank similarly to how it did in the recent past

If a site has a single responsive version of a page then there shouldn’t really be much impact, as the URL is the same. one potential issue is in the past on desktop Google claimed content which was hidden from default view might count less, whereas on smaller mobile screens condensing content blocks down to extensible divs is more common & Google is claiming they will treat such content as visible for ranking purposes

If a site uses separate URLs for desktop vs mobile (like www. for desktop site & m. versions of mobile URLs) & is correctly canonicalized then link metrics into the desktop version of a page should still drive rank for the mobile version of a page

Over the long term their goal is to shift people toward using a single URL for any piece of content. But I suspect the “opportunity” of mobile search to keep decreasing as

Website monetization remains tough for everyone but Google, Facebook & Amazon (check out how much TripAdvisor has struggled of late & they are only monetizing mobile searches at something like 1/3 the rate of desktop searches)

Ads further dominate the search interface on mobile devices

Google roles out more vertical search / vertical ad categories & pushes structured search formats into adopting AMP

AMP further displaces the traditional organic result set by making it that much harder for an unpaid mobile Google search click to lead to a site other than

Services like AMP pull content off the websites & make it only that much harder for the original publisher to monetize their content, engage with their users and generate links & shares that lead directly to their websites

Mike King – Digital Marketing Consultant, Speaker and Founder of iPullRank, a boutique Digital Marketing Agency. Follow him on Twitter.

Mike King, CEO of iPull Rank


What are the key changes do you see in the SEO landscape in 2017?

Mike King:

The SEO landscape is continuing its shift back to its technical upbringing. The expansion of web technologies and Google’s focus on speed and structured data to inform a wider array of mobile and vocal search applications will change the how users interact with search and where SEO’s spend their time. If you’re not thinking mobile first, you won’t win in 2017.

Larry Kim – Speaker, Columnist, Founder of WordStream , a Software Firm ( Internet Marketing Software). Follow him on Twitter.

CEO of MobileMonkey


Penguin 4.0 devalues spam links rather than penalizing entire sites – how do you think this change will affect the SEO landscape?

Larry Kim:

It’s less punitive and makes negative SEO less of a problem, but might embolden more aggressive link spamming. So around and around we go…

Debra Mastaler, Founder of Alliance Link, a Digital Marketing Agency. Follow her on Twitter

Debra Mastaler, Founder of Link Alliance


Many SEO evangelists have been advocating for some time now, particularly after, Google’s aggressive manual penalty drive, that putting ‘Link Earning’ over ‘Link building’ is the way to go. What’s your take on this?
…and what types of link building tactics do you think will work in 2017?

Debra Mastaler:

Good link building is and will always be about earning trust, both from an algorithmic and human standpoint.

Humans link out to pages they value, search engines reward authoritative and trusted pages. In the end, the value of a link is judged by both on the level of trust it will bring.

Successful link building in 2017 will be dependent on several issues: finding solid sources to host your links, creating unique content that attracts attention and developing key partnerships.

Content competition is huge and will only get harder in time. Find ways to attract focused attention and you’ll have an easier time attracting links.

Andrew Shotland – Local SEO Consultant, Columnist and Founder of LocalSEOGuide. Follow him on Twitter.

Andrew Shotland, Founder of LocalSEOGuide


Do you think Google will continue to hide more data from SEOs? How do you think the SEO industry will cope with this challenge?

Andrew Shotland:

Google will continue to change the playing field for SEOs as it always has done. Since SEOs are by nature a curious lot, they will continue to adapt to Google’s changes by doing what they always do – a combination of best practices and pushing the envelope to stress-test Google’s algorithmic updates. Whenever Google releases an update, it naturally breaks something in the algorithm that creates opportunity.

Excerpt from further conversations Kavin Paulson, Editor of The iMarketing Cafe, had with Andrew Shotland:

Kavin Paulson: Thanks Andrew.

Google has been gradually reducing the data they share with webmasters – they hid data w.r.t PR, Keyword data (Not provided) and recently ‘keyword volume figures’ in keyword planner ( available only to advertisers now ) – so with respect to that I thought you would discuss a bit about the next possible data type that they may hide from us and what will be the consequences if they continue to reduce the amount of data they share with us.

Would love to know your take on this.

Andrew Shotland:

I don’t worry about them hiding more data. I am more focused on the problems with the data Google already provides. See this post about how when you compare data across different Google tools (GSC, GMB Insights, GA, etc.) it doesn’t add up

So stop worry about what Google is going to take away from you next. Whatever it is was probably not accurate in the first place.

KP: Interesting perspective… but you need to rely on some data based on which you work out or fine-tune your strategy… even though we know that the data is not very accurate.. first-hand data from Google seems to be something that the SEOs will never ignore .. so Google taking consecutive steps to hide data from webmasters is a cause of concern for many SEOs

AS: First hand data from Google is basically religion. People will believe what they want to believe.

KP: Ha ha… your point is well taken!

A J Ghergich – SEO Consultant, Columnist and founder of Ghergich & Co, an Internet Marketing Agency. Follow him on Twitter.

AJ Ghergich, SEO Consultant


How do you think the personal assistant devices like Google Home, Amazon Echo etc. will impact SEO in 2017?

AJ Ghergich:

How do you think the personal assistant devices like Google Home, Amazon Echo etc. will impact SEO in 2017?

As consumers integrate virtual assistants into their homes it be more important than ever to earn Featured Snippets from Google. Many of the searches consumers use on devices like Google Home are going to be question based which is perfect for Featured Snippets.

For Example:

Google Answer

Google is becoming more and more of an answer engine instead of just a search engine. Your goal in 2017 should be to make your site have the very best answers to the questions in your vertical.

Cyrus Shepard – Online Marketing and SEO consultant, Founder of Fazillion Media and Former Head of SEO and Content at Moz. Follow him on Twitter.

Cyrus Shepard, SEO Consultant


Apart from Links, Content and RankBrain (top 3 ranking factors as revealed by Google’s Andrey Lipattsev), in that order, which ranking factor do you think will have more weight in 2017?

Cyrus Shepard:

There are a few areas smart SEOs and marketers may want to focus on in 2017:

1. Mobile content. Why? Because Google announced they are soon moving to a mobile-first index. While they are still working out how exactly this will work, it essentially means that your rankings will depend more on your mobile content than your desktop content.

From this, it’s not a difficult stretch to imagine that Google will also base rankings on your mobile experience, as well – much the same way that Google’s Panda algorithm judges the quality of a site’s content and other algorithms may evaluate user engagement metrics.

2. Answers, answers, answers! Google keeps improving the quality+quantity of featured snippets in SERPs, and we’ve seen sites that can grab these coveted spots see a big boost in traffic. Apart from these snippets, it seems reasonable that Google constantly evaluates how well sites provide satisfying answers to keyword queries. Working to provide clear, fast, and accurate answers would be a winning strategy.

3. AMP. While this isn’t a ranking factor per se, we do see sites that have implemented AMP get featured prominently in news boxes and in mobile apps. While I’m personally not a fan of the semi-closed ecosystem Google has created with AMP, look for it to figure more prominently in 2017.

Gabriella Sannino – International Marketing Consultant and SEO Strategist. Owner of Level343, an International Marketing & SEO Company. Follow her on Twitter.

Gabriella Sannino, International SEO Consultant


What are the challenges do you think SEOs will face or have to tackle in 2017?

Gabriella Sannino:

I think the biggest challenge by far will be integrating mobile search into the marketing fray. Not just making sure a website is mobile friendly, but all the things that mobile entails.

We’re at the frontier of “science fiction meets marketing” here. Voice search, location search, long-tail queries, instant answers and even artificial intelligence are coming to the forefront. We should already be devising strategies to combat those challenges in order to bring the best results to the client.


Kavin Paulson


Kavin is a seasoned digital marketer with more than 10 years of hands-on experience handling multiple projects of various clients from different industries. A decade-long career in digital marketing has helped him gain diverse skill sets, rich experience and in-depth knowledge of how things work in the digital ecosystem. As a digital marketing consultant over a period of 10+ years, he has led many digital marketing campaigns to achieve set objectives and have delivered impressive results. Apart from working on digital marketing projects and handling clients, he does read, analyze and write about all things digital. "I welcome you to the community and invite you to be a part of it. Hope you like what we do here at The iMarketing Café. Your valuable suggestions and feedback is always welcome. Stay tuned!" - Kavin

Related Posts

Image implies Artificial IntelligenceSEO: Redefining Theory, Policy and Practice ( Part II )
Rand Fishkin, Founder of MozThe Ultimate List of Twitter Handles of SEO Experts
Debra Mastaler, Founder of Link AllianceThe Experts Speak: The One Big Change Expected in the SEO Landscape in 2016


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *